push and pull metrics

who should send the metrics

push and pull metrics

metrics from A to B

who should send the metrics

push vs pull metrics

Metrics, a snapshot view of counters and guages representing an aggregated state of a system. Implementing it comes with a big debate of do you push or pull your metrics from a collector, and do you use cumulative or delta temporality in aggregating your data.

Prometheus have a nice doc further elaborating on decisions, especially wrt to Prometheus / OpenTelemetry Promteheus / OTLP.

dimensions

push vs pull

push

• metrics producer is responsible for sending metrics
• producer in full control over temporal resolution
• harder for receivers to load balance / shed
• no exposed endpoints for producer
• ability to flush on exit

pull

• any number of receivers without change
• receiver in control over distributing load
• requires service discovery
• creates an implicit check

delta vs cumulative

delta

• producer retains minimal state / no historical values
• sensitive to loss of intermediate samples

cumulative

• requires smarter query functions
• hard to reliably convert to delta after the fact